Is DKIM actually set up on your domain? In the Mailwarm network study, we found a DKIM key on common selectors for only about a third of sending domains. Here's how to check yours, and why "not found" often doesn't mean what you think.
DKIM is a digital signature on every email you send. Your server signs each message with a private key. Receivers check it against a public key published in your DNS, at selector._domainkey.yourdomain.com. If it matches, the email is authentic and unchanged. And it's the only one of SPF, DKIM and DMARC that survives forwarding.
Open the free DKIM checker from Mailwarm, the email warmup and deliverability monitoring tool built by a Y Combinator team. Type your domain. Don't know your selector? Leave it blank: the tool tries the common ones. Here's mailwarm.com.
Green: DKIM record valid. The selector it found is google, so Google Workspace signs this domain's mail. Below, the record itself. v=DKIM1 is the version, k=rsa the key type, and p is the public key. This one is a 2048-bit key. That's what you want.
Now watch this. Same domain, with selector1, the Microsoft 365 selector. Not found. The domain has DKIM, just not under that name. So before you assume DKIM is missing, check the selector.
Google Workspace uses google. Microsoft 365 uses selector1 and selector2. SendGrid uses s1 and s2. For any provider, open an email you sent, show the original, and find s= in the DKIM-Signature line. That's your selector. d= is the signing domain.
If DKIM still fails, three common causes. The key was pasted wrong: stray quotes, spaces, or split badly across DNS strings. The key is 1024-bit: still accepted, but weak. Rotate to 2048. Or something changed the email after signing, like a forwarder or security gateway adding a footer. That breaks the body hash.
DKIM is one of three. Check SPF and DMARC next. Passing all three proves who you are. It doesn't prove you're trusted. A new domain still needs warmup to build a sending history. That's what Mailwarm does. Check your DKIM record free. The link is in the description. And when you add a new email tool, check its selector too.